The Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace at the Vatican issued a document on October 24 entitled, "Toward Reforming the International Financial and Monetary Systems in the Context of Global Public Authority." It was the lead story linked at DrudgeReport to the Reuters news service. The document denounced "neo-liberal thinking", greed and hoarding as the source of the world's economic ills. The document called for the establishment of "a supranational authority" with "universal jurisdiction" to guide economic policies and decisions.
According to the Reuters report, Cardinal Peter Turkson responded as to whether the document could become a manifesto for the movement of the "indignant ones" (who started the ball rolling in Spain which continues to make its way in Occupy Wall Street demonstrations throughout the U.S.) who have criticized global economic policies. Cardinal Turkson, who heads the Vatican's Justice and Peace department, said "The people on Wall Street need to sit down and go through a process of discernment and see whether their role managing the finances of the world is actually serving the interests of humanity and the common good."
Commenting on it was Bill Donohue of the U.S.-based Catholic League. The leader of the advocacy group declared, "There has been much hyperventilation from some quarters over the release of this document. All of it is unwarranted. To begin with, the text is not an encyclical, nor is it the work of Pope Benedict XVI. Much of what it says is consistent with long-standing Catholic social teaching: the quest for the common good should guide social and economic policy. It properly calls for "abandoning all forms of petty selfishness and embracing the logic of the global common good."
Donohue, who frequently defends Catholic positions on social policy, also said "Much of the early chatter focuses on the document's call for a global authority to render economic justice. It says, "Benedict XVI himself expressed the need to create a world political authority." The reference is to the pope's encyclical, Caritas in Veritate . The term "world political authority" appears once in the encyclical, the context of which is a plea for "international cooperation" in the pursuit of a more just "political, juridical and economic order." In the very next sentence, the Holy Father stresses that such an authority must "observe consistently the principles of subsidiarity and solidarity."
The document released on October 24 also emphasizes the need to follow the Catholic principle of subsidiarity. According to Donohue, "This means that solutions to social and economic problems should begin at the most local level, not at the national, much less the international, level. Indeed, the pope explicitly said in his 2009 encyclical that 'subsidiarity is the most effective antidote against any form of all-encompassing welfare state.'"
Striking a contrast between Pope Benedict's previous statements about the world economy, Donohue noted that the "statement uses terms like 'supranational Authority' and 'supranational Institution.'" He added," These neologisms are purely the creation of the authors, Cardinal Peter Turkson and Mario Toso. They are not found in the pope's encyclical. No matter, those who are comparing this text to the demands of the "Occupy Wall Street" crowd should first detail what exactly it is the urban campers want."